Thursday, July 2, 2009

WTF?

So today I go to the post office to collect a package. There’s a little booth set up under the post office arcade: the Argyle International Airport Information booth. There’re brochures, a huge map, a television, and a couple of smiling, friendly people taking questions and so on. What’s the big deal, right? So ok, there’s a booth; that’s a good thing, right?

Of course it’s a good thing. Vincentians do need more information about the new airport. It’s marvelous that the government has set up this information point so people can find out more about such an immense, national undertaking. Of course, the actual information is watered-down for public consumption but, obviously, people only need to know certain things, and in simple language.

Here’s what upset me when I saw this. Oh yeah, did I mention that I am upset? I am, in fact, livid. Just to be clear, I am fit to be tied.

Where’s the information booth for matters pertaining to the Proposed Constitution of SVG 2009?

This airport is not scheduled to be completed for another two years (at least – this is what we’ve been told). The decision to build an international airport has already been made – the earthworks have begun. There’s no longer any real argument as to the future existence of this thing. The proposed Constitution, however, is not a done deal. The referendum vote is in what, two months? Three?

In order to gain access to a copy of the proposed Constitution, one has a few options:
  • drive to Campden Park, get a ticket, drive to town, present ticket to some bureaucrat, pay said bureaucrat, collect receipt, drive back to Campden Park, collect document (drive between town and Campden Park could be anywhere between 15 – 30 mins depending on traffic);
  • go to the government website and download in compartmentalized, highly inefficient pdf format;
  • be lucky enough to have entire pdf documented e-mailed to you via forward; or,
  • I don’t know, but there may be other options.

I have it on pdf, but it’s difficult to read because, well, reading anything for too long on my laptop screen makes my migraines act up. I’d like the actual hardcopy document, but have yet to do the whole yellow brick road collection dance. Printing the entire document will cost more than purchasing it.

If I want information on the new airport, I just need to pick up a convenient brochure at the centrally located booth. If, on the other hand, I want to get a hold of the proposed Constitution, or if I want information on it, I need to go through hell. Which is more immediate and important to this country right now? The extraordinarily well publicized (or propagandized) Argyle Airport, or the woefully under exposed Constitution?

The ramifications (both positive and negative) of a new airport are obvious and have been discussed in the public forum for several years now: boost in national revenue, increased tourism, ease of international travel, job creation, massive international debt, selling our collective souls etc etc.

The proposed Constitution, however, is not getting much official play. Yeah there’s the occasional edification programme on television – the language used being way above the heads of most people; and yeah there’ve been newspaper articles (rather, letters to the editor). But the government has been remarkably close-mouthed and secretive about the proposed Constitution. Apparently, concerned citizens have until July 11th to lodge any formal oppositions to the document. This date has not been widely publicized; it has been announced a mere handful of times on the radio. The announcements would’ve been easy to miss.

What are we left to conclude? Forgive me, what am I left to conclude? I know my brain does not always work in the most linear fashion, but doesn’t it strike anyone else as odd that the Argyle Airport, a project that is more or less a fait accompli, is getting public education play, while the proposed Constitution is basically being treated like an irksome piece of paper to be swept under the rug?

Let me put this another way. Am I to conclude that the makers of the constitution have their own agenda? Is it possible that the whole idea is to get it slipped in, under the public radar, so that it becomes a done deal before we even realize it? And who benefits most from this strategy?

I’m so much in favour of a new constitution, but the current proposed document has some flaws. It does not necessarily give us the rights that we should be expecting from a Republican Constitution. It purports to be a document that will help shape our new republic but, at the same time, restricts some of the rights expected from a republic. We do not, realistically, have enough time to properly study this document before we have to vote on it; in fact, one of the country’s three QCs publicly stated this some time ago. If a QC doesn’t have enough time to properly peruse the implications of the proposed Constitution, how on Earth am I, Mr. Johnny Public, supposed to be able to? Especially when its importance is being so downplayed in the mainstream?

What’s more important RIGHT NOW? Educating us about an airport, or educating us about something that will change the way our country is run forever?

16 wonderful people responded... will you?:

hbynoe said...

I smell a dictatorship steaming away in its juices.

more later!

Jdid said...

why would they want to make your life easy? if you really interested you will make an effort to procur by hook or crook the constitution document. well at least i see that as the logic.

brochures and smiling people giving you assistance in understanding the constitution only leads to more questions when the men wanta force it down ya craw. so put up ya face like when ya mudda force ya ta drink cod liver oil and swallow wha de people gi ya.

Lion-ess said...

That needed to be said. I think us laymen don't even fully comprehend the constitution when read. Shouldn't there be forums and programmes to educate the public about the Constitution and its consequences.

What is the opposition party doing? what about the big educators, lawyers, historians etc doing? Is there any agency or person in St Vincent educating the public?

Or is the constitution only for the understanding of the select few?

Will said...

@ hbynoe: yes... i don't think you're the only person who feels this way... it's a possibility, although i really don't think that's going to happen... hmmm... but you never know...

@ jdid: lol... sadly, i think you're right...

Antillean said...

That is silly. I hear that the drafters are working to release a document that will detail the differences between the current constitution and the proposed constitution some time this month. But it should be really, really obvious to the government that we really don't have enough time to wait for such a document.

So yeah, I agree with you. There should be a vigorous education and information campaign on the constitution. It should be about as ubiquitous as carnival. People shouldn't be able to put on their radios for more than a few minutes or walk more than a block in town and not hear or see something to do with the new constitution.

But even if that is done, I wonder if it would have the kind of impact that it should. How much civics can you teach people through informational booths and advertisements in a few months? That is perhaps difficult enough for single measures, how much harder will it be for an entirely new constitution? And in a political climate like ours?

I don't see any of this to excuse the government. Regardless of the difficulties, the government should be putting its best foot forward here and it really seems like that isn't what's happening here. (Though, come to think of it, I don't think the opposition or the majority of civil society are puptting their best feet forward either.)

And what rights that we should expect from a republican constitution does it not give?

Batman. said...

i think i'm the only person who sorta feels that it doesn't really matter what happens in the constitutional reform.....

life will go on...it may be harder....it may be easier...may be 1 more level of redtape...

i will vote on it though not because of my feelings on how it will affect me but my feelings on how it will affect others around me...but there are some things in it i'm honestly interested in...

i'm a lab technician...i'll hate my job no matter how much life changes.

but life will go on...



also did y'all see the papers? notice on the toxscreen coke isn't there....as i said who the f has enough coke to put in a cake? and again i go back to thinking it was plain old food poisoning.

Abeni said...

The Govt will say that there was a committee in place to deal with Constitutional Reform. therefore, it's their responsibility to bring all matters re constitutions to the masses.

In another note I got my IADC flyer and was happy to note the airport will be ready by 2012:)

Abeni said...

Oh Global Voices got ya.

Empath said...

Bad omen. Dark clouds are gathering over this constitution biz.

blahblohblog said...

See now, I suspect you have some kind of belief that 98% of your fellow countrymen actually care about constitutional reform. Didn't I mention to you the other day that I am surprised you guys are even changing your constitution, much less having a referendum on it?

Call me elitist but I shudder to think of "ordinary Grenadians" really having a direct influence on our Constitution! We have far too many uninformed, uneducated - and frankly STUPID - people here! They don't want to be educated (and thus question the system Jdid), they just want the status quo. "Ordinary people" here just too damn happy.

Can I ask you something in all seriousness? Do you really think that Vincentians will pass, by REFERENDUM, a constitutional amendment redefining marriage for instance? The arguments you and the commenters brought up in your earlier post are completely valid, but don't you feel like one voice amid thousands of people who just don't care and will definitely not vote for it in any case?

Maybe not what we would like to think, but I am not sure us people are as open-minded and capable of rational thought as we would hope.

---
Uh.. right that was a downer of a comment so... for some levity... *shaking booty* Luv Ya Will!!

Ruthibelle said...

You know what I'm always suggestin... modernised constitutional language. The constitution was witten in some pretty ooold language. Even if the average man read it, it would sound like complete jibbrish. Why government nuh spen time translate the thing out of legalese and old english mumbo-jumbo and put it into terms the everyday man can understand??

I agree, Will, that our governements' priorities often seem REALLY messed up??

THe bottomline is top dollar so the rights of the average man gets buried... and ignored.

Guyana-Gyal said...

Don't lemme start on what I think of C'bean govts.......man look...all o' dem is de same...

...mother hollering to me to have breakfast with her again.

Guyana-Gyal said...

They function [or malfunction] on the basis that people like the pretty things.

Will said...

Hello everyone. I,m in Mayreau until Wednesday. Have been here since Friday. There's no internet access so I tiefin a few minutes on friend's bberry but is very frustrating. Will update and moderate comments again on wednesday whenm I get back to st. Vincent.

Later!

heaven said...

Caribbean governments know that the "average" citizen is not interested in serious matters. That is why it is so difficult to get a copy of the proposed document. Only the truly committed will submit to the song and dance required to get a copy.
The airport is a done deal but the Government knows how to manipulate people.Make them think they are part of the process.
This is how things are in politics.Put up a smoke screen to distract from the important issues.

Will said...

@ lioness: there were consultations on what to include on the draft... but i am not certain how well attended they were... i went to one at the school i was teaching in at the time...

what we need now is, as you see, more public education now that the document has been published for review...

@ kamal: i think apathy is one of the worse diseases of our current society...

@ batman: see... this is the apathy i'm talking about... so what if, realistically, you feel like you can change nothing? does that mean you shouldn't take an interest?

@ abeni: of course... if is one thing we excel at here is passing the buck...

@ empath: so true... i wonder what it all portends...

@ bbb: woooo... booteh!!! but seriously... i know what the reality is... but this doesn't mean that i can't dream... sigh...

@ ruthi: you are so right... if we had a sort of "fun with dick and jane" type constitution for us non-legalese speakers life would be much easier and many many more us of would get involved...

@ gg: this is, unfortunately, very true... "the people" generally tend to be easily bought... i, myself, am partial to a sheet of galvanize, a few lengths of lumber and a couple bags of cement once every four/five years...

@ heaven: and you see, we all KNOW this and it still works... why???